IN HIS OWN WORDS | Yoav Potash Shares a Scene from “Crime After Crime”

In Yoav Potash’s first full-length feature documentary, “Crime After Crime,” the filmmaker went to great lengths to follow the epic legal battle to free Deborah Peagler. To gain access to the maximum-security prison in Chowchilla, California where Peagler was incarcerated, he used a two-pronged approach; first he embedded himself with Peagler’s pro-bono attorneys as her official legal videographer, and second, he made an entirely separate documentary about the rehabilitative programs at the prison – a project that acted as a sort of Trojan horse to surreptitiously transport Potash and his crew inside the prison gates.

The plan appears to have worked.  “Crime After Crime” has earned numerous top festival awards and garnered some great notices following its world premiere at Sundance. Below, find an exclusive scene from the film and Potash’s thoughts on the process.

The Scene

The sequence that I’ve chosen for indieWIRE shows how Deborah Peagler’s case began to transform — from a private legal brief quietly argued by her two attorneys — into a public battle waged on front page headlines, in TV news reports, and in the court of public opinion.

To provide some context, I’ve started this excerpt at the end of a previous scene, where attorney Joshua Safran stands at a whiteboard, laying out the legal strategy five years into the case. The shot is literally a “back to the drawing board” moment – half an hour earlier in the film (at the start of the film’s second act) we saw Joshua at this same whiteboard, outlining the uphill battle he envisioned for winning his client’s freedom when he began working on the case in 2002. 

The whiteboard motif emerged from workshopping the film with test audiences. Throughout the five and a half years of making this film, we held work-in-progress screenings to help me determine which scenes were working, and to identify scenes where audiences weren’t connecting with what we had. (We also used these events as opportunities to fundraise for the film). In early cuts, the legal process confused some audience members, so I went back and asked Joshua to stand in front of a white board and diagram the strategy in plain English. We tested it out at our next rough cut screening and audiences really loved it, so coming back to the whiteboard for a reorientation when the case began to escalate was a natural extension of the motif.

We then insert a timeline graphic, another motif element of the film that is repeated as Debbie and her lawyers push through year after year of their saga.  A news clip from Oakland’s KTVU Fox-2 News does a nice job of quickly contrasting the lawyers’ current efforts with their original concept of what they imagined would be an open-and-shut case, and once we cut to footage of an outdoor concert where Speech of Arrested Development is talking about Deborah’s plight to a crowd of thousands, it’s clear that her case is getting bigger than anyone ever imagined.

Victim Advocate Position In California - News


IN HIS OWN WORDS | Yoav Potash Shares a Scene from “Crime After Crime”
IN HIS OWN WORDS | Yoav Potash Shares a Scene from “Crime After Crime”

Over time, however, working on the film has transformed me into a vocal advocate for all victims of domestic violence, especially those who would otherwise be forgotten and denied justice. This is why, alongside the release of the film, I am working to



Palin/Perry 2012: For 16 Years of Conservative Bliss

Why advocate for Palin when she is not (as of yet running) and we have Michele Bachmann who has the courage and fortitutde to throw her hat in the ring. Bachmann shares Palin's conservative values and in my opinion is a good deal more articulate and



Canto appointed as Superior Court judge

During his legal career, Judge-nominee Canto was a public defender, an advocate for the defense of those who could not afford an attorney, and a very successful defense attorney. He has extensive trial, arbitration, and mediation experience in criminal



DA's office to lose 14 prosecutors

The DA's Victorville office has lost four prosecutors (15 percent), one investigator, one investigative technician, one witness coordinator and one victim advocate during the same period. Tomoya Shimura may be reached at (760) 955-5368 or



Sheriff's office employees say farewells at retirement lunch

"If you look at a crime scene person, he is the only advocate the victim has, especially with homicides," Moyle said. "I've got to be good at what I do because that's the only person who is going to say or go after the individual who killed them or




Woman gets 16 years to life for murdering boyfriend -Sacramento ...

District Attorney Jan Scully announced that Kathryn Spiak was sentenced by the Honorable Judge John Winn to 16 years to life for the murder of her boyfriend Jeremy Jones.  Spiak pled no contest to second degree murder plus the use of a knife.

In December 2010, the couple got into an argument at their Rancho Cordova apartment and Jones physically assaulted Spiak.  After the argument, Jones went to take a shower.  Spiak then grabbed two knives from the kitchen and stabbed their bed numerous times.  When she broke both knives stabbing the bed, she went to the kitchen and retrieved another knife.  Jones came into the room and saw Spiak holding the knife.  After Jones told her that she wouldn't kill him, Spiak stabbed him twice in the chest.    

Deputy District Attorney Carlton Davis stated, "Justice was served in this case. I want to give special recognition to District Attorney Victim Advocate Colette Brown for all of her assistance throughout the court process.


Victim Advocate Position In California - Bookshelf

The Toughest Beat, Politics, Punishment, and the Prison Officers Union in California

The Toughest Beat, Politics, Punishment, and the Prison Officers Union in California

Later, in April 2006 Governor Schwarzenegger created a cabinet position called the “Crime Victim Advocate” to “serve as California's lead advocate on state ...

Compulsion and control: Sex crime and criminal justice policy in California, 1930--2007

Compulsion and control: Sex crime and criminal justice policy in California, 1930--2007

I have focused in this chapter on the rise of single issue victim advocacy organizations which push for policy change and often push for punitive responses . ...

Gang investigations, a street cop's guide

Gang investigations, a street cop's guide

Gang Victim Services In 1990, Orange County applied for a special emphasis ... entry-level Victim Advocate Training program, as mandated by California Penal ...

Great Jobs for Foreign Language Majors

Great Jobs for Foreign Language Majors

Victim Advocate The employment outlook for victim advocates is strong, ... Court Reporter Job opportunities for court reporters are expected to be excellent ...

Great Jobs for Criminal Justice Majors

Great Jobs for Criminal Justice Majors

Victim Advocate The employment outlook for victim advocates is strong, ... California employs approximately 5700 bailiffs, while North Dakota employs only ...

Detailed Information Directory


Child Advocate Jobs in California on iHireSocialServices.com
Find all California Child Advocate Jobs at iHireSocialServices.com. ... In the subject line, list the position number (CM-002 San Jose) ?Forward your resume to ...

victims advocate jobs in USA | careerjet.com
All victims advocate jobs in USA on Careerjet.com, the search engine for jobs in the USA

victim jobs in USA | careerjet.com
All victim jobs in USA on Careerjet.com, the search engine for jobs in the USA

Seeking to reduce redundancy, Schwarzenegger creates new ...
Seeking to reduce redundancy, Schwarzenegger creates new position for crime victims' advocate ... advocate, to in part help coordinate services for crime victims at ...

Position statement in support of Latina victim advocates
Position statement in support of Latina victim advocates. An URGENT CALL to address the national shortage of Latina victim advocates in the U.S. ...